In part 1 John & Georgia were frantically sampling today’s mortgage landscape for one of those 30 year loans we all hear about that are now in the high 4’s & low 5% range. As you remember, thay have a hybrid fixed to ARM loan that is about to convert to an adjustable and felt the only move that made sense was to get a new fixed rate. See Do You Really Need to Refinance - part 1.
What was your conclusion? Or better said what would have been the right thing for you to do if you had to choose?
John & Georgia did not fully understand their current loan. They mistakenly concluded that once the loan was an adjustable, their rate and payments would skyrocket, they would not be able to afford the new payments, loose control, and have to deal with yet higher future payments.
We examined a 3 year chart of this index to see the unusually low and attractive rates this index is serving up. They could see the most severe changes occurred from August of 07 through January of 09, and surmised that degree of activity is not likely to repeat itself as the economy recovers very slowly and index values rise. This index being a 12 month running average, this could take some time.
So here are the facts they used to choose:
- New interest rate in August (index + margin) will be close to 3.25%
- New monthly payment for 1 year will be $1,018 per month saving them $744.67 each month for that year.
- Their current loan balance stays the same, a savings of $3,900 over refinancing
- The additional monthly cash savings could be saved to be applied to principal later if they need to or used for any other purpose like payment relief in case John does loose his job.
Taking the conservative approach, John and Georgia now look several years out to make some assessments about what might happen and the impact of that. Below is a chart representing their calculations based on these assumptions:
- Their interest rate increases 1.25% each year
- They continue making interest only loan payments until the option discontinues
- They save the difference each month in and account that has a 3.25% rate of return
- If property value increases in 3-5 years they will sell and move to a larger home.
|
Yearly amount saved from previous payments |
Interest rate |
Cumulative balance with interest at the end of each year |
|
Year 1 = $8,936.04 |
3.25% |
$9.253.87 |
|
Year 2 = $4,230.00 |
4.5% |
$13,963.45 |
|
Year 1 = -$470 |
5.75% |
$14,460.09 |
|
Average rate for 3 years |
4.5% |
|
|
Average 3 yr savings |
|
$4,230 |
John & Georgia chose to stick with this index, the adjustable portion of the loan and direct what they save to either additional down payment in the future when they purchase again or, if they are fortunate with their finances and employment, to begin college savings accounts for their two children.



